Nov 13

Sweet 16 Dinner in NYC: Italian Rooms for a Teen Table

The cheat sheetSweet 16 dinner in NYC: seven Italian restaurants compared on published party sizes, set-menu prices, deposits and time limits, with what to ask before booking.

Of seven Italian restaurants checked, only Angelina’s Ristorante on Staten Island prints a Sweet 16 menu: $68 per person plus tax and a 22% fee, for ages 16 and under. In Manhattan, Rubirosa takes groups of 8 to 22, Rosemary’s East Side seats a communal table of up to 16, and Tony’s Di Napoli requires a party package from 15 guests. Hours, prices and policies below come from each restaurant’s own website, checked in October 2026. None of the six Manhattan pages prints a price specific to teenagers.

What are some good Italian venues for a Sweet 16 dinner in NYC?

Rows start with the smallest headcount at which each rule applies, and Angelina’s comes last because its page names no party size. “None printed” means none on the pages read.

Restaurant Address Headcount rule Friday and Saturday Age or teen line on the page
Da Andrea (Greenwich Village) 35 West 13th Street 8 minimum, 30 maximum; “semi-private” on its event deck, no private dining space per its large-group page Friday 11:30 a.m. to 11 p.m.; Saturday 11 a.m. to 11 p.m. FAQ: “a comfortable choice for families and guests of all ages”
Tarallucci e Vino (Union Square) 15 East 18th Street Prix fixe required at 8 or more; Mezzanine seats 10 to 38 Friday 8am to 10pm; Saturday 9am to 10pm None printed
Rubirosa 235 Mulberry Street Groups of 8 to 22, family-style 11AM to 11PM daily None printed
Rosemary’s East Side 350 1st Avenue Communal table for 11 to 16 on a seasonal prix fixe, which the page calls ideal for “birthday celebrations” Dinner 4:00 PM to 10:30 PM None printed for the communal table
Eataly Flatiron 200 Fifth Avenue Events from “an intimate dinner for 12” to “a gala for 300”; no minimum printed La Pizza & La Pasta 11:00AM to 10:30PM daily None printed
Tony’s Di Napoli (Times Square) 147 West 43rd Street Package required at 15 or more Tuesday to Saturday 11:30AM to 11PM “Children between the ages of 3-11 are priced at $30 per child”
Angelina’s Ristorante 399 Ellis St, Staten Island (page footer) Sweet 16 menu; no party size printed Menu Tuesday to Friday only “Ages 16 and under”

Each restaurant’s own site publishes a party size, a room capacity or a set price for groups, and Angelina’s is here as the only Sweet 16 menu found. This compares published terms and is not a ranking. Read the headcounts as ceilings: a 23rd guest ends Rubirosa, a 31st ends Da Andrea’s semi-private space and a 39th ends Tarallucci’s Mezzanine. Rosemary’s East Side books regular tables to 10 guests and sends 17 or more to private rooms by inquiry.

How much does a table of 12 cost at these restaurants?

As of October 2026, four of the seven print a per-guest price for a group or party. The totals below are arithmetic on those prices for 12 guests, in dollars, before drinks, tax, gratuity and fees.

  • Tony’s Di Napoli: 588 for Package 1 (one salad, two pastas and one entree), 708 for Package 2 and 768 for Package 3, from planner prices of 49, 59 and 64 dollars per person. Its page requires a package from 15 guests, so ask whether one is offered at 12. Private rooms are listed at both locations, though the planner guarantees none without a separately signed agreement.
  • Tarallucci e Vino: 780 for the $65 dinner prix fixe, or 360 for the $30 brunch prix fixe.
  • Angelina’s Ristorante: 816 at $68 per person, before New York State tax and the 22% administration fee.
  • Da Andrea: 1,020 for the $85 dinner, or 780 for the $65 brunch.

From Tony’s Package 1 to Da Andrea’s dinner is a 432-dollar spread for 12, but not like for like. Da Andrea’s event deck says its prix fixe “does not include any beverages”; Tony’s prices drinks in a separate per-person step: Sodas & Juices at $6.00, sangria, house wines and beer at $29.00, a premium open bar at $44.00. With the soda step added, Package 1 is 55 dollars a guest (660 for 12) and Package 2 is 65 (780). Tony’s adds a 20% discretionary gratuity and 8.875% sales tax; Da Andrea’s bill carries tax and a 20% gratuity. The planner is dated April 2026 in its file name, so confirm prices; the rest of Tony’s terms are in family-style birthday dinners in NYC.

What does Angelina’s Sweet 16 menu include, and what needs a question?

Angelina’s is the only per-person price here that includes unlimited soda: “Unlimited soda, coffee, espresso, cappuccino and gourmet tea”. Entrees include chicken parmigiano and chicken fingers and french fries. A cocktail hour is listed at an additional $10 with no unit printed, and “Prices are subject to change.”

Several lines need a question. If the 22% fee is figured on the 68 dollars, a guest costs about 83 dollars before tax. The “Mandatory Security Guard $350 per 50 teens” works out to 7 dollars per teen at a full 50, and the page does not say how a smaller group is billed. The menu reads “Ages 16 and under”, so ask how a 17- or 18-year-old guest is handled. The footer lists 399 Ellis St for Angelina’s Ristorante and Angelina’s Kitchen addresses in Staten Island and Woodbridge Township, New Jersey; the menu names no location, so confirm where the party would be held.

Which deadlines do the pages print, counted back from party day?

Three of the seven print any deadline: Tony’s, Tarallucci e Vino and Da Andrea. Rubirosa, Rosemary’s East Side, Eataly and Angelina’s print none on the pages read.

  • At booking: Tony’s wants a contract and a 20% deposit. Tarallucci e Vino wants a card on file from 6 guests. Da Andrea secures up to 25 guests with a card and asks 25% from 26; its large-group page calls that deposit non-refundable, while the event deck says it is fully refunded when cancelled more than 7 days out, so ask which applies.
  • 7 days: Tony’s final guest count is due one week before. Inside 7 days, Da Andrea charges $25 per person plus tax for a cancellation by a group of up to 25.
  • 3 days: Da Andrea’s final count is due at least 3 days before.
  • 24 hours: Tarallucci e Vino charges $35 per person for a no-show, a cancellation under 24 hours or a same-day reduction of three or more guests.

Da Andrea also requires a food and beverage minimum with no figure printed: if fewer guests attend, the client “remains responsible for the full agreed minimum”. Rosemary’s East Side lists no minimum for the communal table, while the Greenhouse (30 seated) lists $2,000 to $5,000 and the Pantry (40 seated, which names kids’ birthday parties among its uses) lists $3,000 to $8,000. More rooms’ card holds and no-show rules are in birthday dinner deposits and no-show fees.

Which nights and end times work for a teen table?

Angelina’s menu is Tuesday to Friday only. Tony’s Package 1 is “Not available Fri. or Sat. after 3 PM”, so a Friday or Saturday evening party starts at Package 2.

Closing time is not party length. Tony’s schedules each party for 2 1/2 hours with departure times “strictly enforced”, so a table seated at 6:30 is out by 9:00, well before its 11PM close. Da Andrea contracts a set duration that includes setup and clean-up. No other page prints a time limit, so ask when the room is needed back.

Is there an option besides a set-menu dinner?

Da Andrea’s FAQ says “Walk-ins are welcome when tables are available”. Eataly’s La Pizza & La Pasta serves “Neapolitan pizza and artisanal pasta” daily from 11:00AM. Eataly Flatiron also lists private classes where guests “Shape pasta, create traditional sauces, or learn the art of gelato”; the page prints no price, age rule or minimum.

What should a parent ask before booking?

Apart from the “Ages 16 and under” line on Angelina’s menu, none of the pages read for this guide states an age rule, a chaperone requirement or a teen price. Ask each room:

  • How a 16-year-old is counted. Tony’s child price is $30 for ages 3 to 11, and the planner prints no separate price for 12 and up.
  • Whether a soft-drink-only option exists for the table, and its price.
  • How alcohol service is handled at a table of mixed ages.
  • Whether any security or staffing charge applies to a party of this size.

On cake, Rubirosa’s group page lists a cake with candles as a birthday add-on, and Da Andrea’s event deck allows outside dessert items, “specifically, a purchased cake”, and no other outside food. Cutting fees are covered in birthday cake policy and cake-cutting fees. For celiac disease or a nut allergy, confirm with the restaurant.

Frequently asked questions

How much does a Sweet 16 dinner cost at a restaurant in NYC?

For 12 guests, printed prices run from 588 dollars at Tony’s Di Napoli Package 1 to 1,020 dollars at Da Andrea’s $85 dinner, before drinks, tax, gratuity and fees. Angelina’s Sweet 16 menu is $68 per person plus tax and a 22% administration fee, as of October 2026.

Is there a Sweet 16 menu at an Italian restaurant in NYC?

Angelina’s Ristorante on Staten Island lists one at $68 per person plus tax and a 22% administration fee, available Tuesday to Friday only, for ages 16 and under. The same page lists a mandatory security guard at $350 per 50 teens, as of October 2026.

Can a Sweet 16 dinner be booked on a Saturday night?

Rubirosa, Da Andrea, Tarallucci e Vino, Rosemary’s East Side and Tony’s Di Napoli all list Saturday hours. Angelina’s Sweet 16 menu is Tuesday to Friday only, and Tony’s Package 1 is not available on Friday or Saturday after 3 PM.

When is the final headcount due for a Sweet 16 dinner?

Tony’s Di Napoli wants its final guest count one week before the party, and Da Andrea at least 3 days before. Tarallucci e Vino charges $35 per person for a same-day reduction of three or more guests, as of October 2026.

↑ Back to the feed

You're invited to the list

One email when a new guide drops — group-dinner spots, cake intel, and etiquette fixes. No spam, just party logistics.

Sent when there's news, never more than weekly.