Gluten-Free or Vegan Birthday Dinner for a Group in NYC
A gluten-free or vegan birthday dinner for a group in NYC often comes down to one question: will the whole table eat from a set menu? Rezdôra’s tasting needs the full table, has no gluten-free version and does have a vegetarian one; Senza Gluten says its kitchen and dining rooms are strictly gluten-free; and John’s of 12th Street prints a full vegan menu. Hours, prices and policies below come from each restaurant’s own website, checked in October 2026; Lavagna’s pages and one Senza Gluten paragraph carry older dates, and Gramercy Tavern’s event kit gives no year. For celiac disease or an allergy, confirm with the restaurant before booking.
Dietary labels and group rules at eight restaurants
| Restaurant | Address | Dietary label printed | Group rule printed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rezdôra | 27 East 20th Street | Vegetarian tasting; no gluten-free tasting | The full table takes the tasting |
| John’s of 12th Street | 302 East 12th Street | Full vegan menu; $2 gluten-free pasta | Minimum 20; back room hosts 70 |
| Rubirosa | 235 Mulberry Street | Gluten-Free menu tab | Groups of 8 to 22 |
| Senza Gluten | 206 Sullivan Street | Strictly gluten-free rooms; names a small contamination risk | None on the pages read |
| Lavagna | 545 East 5th Street | Group menus tailored to restrictions; 2015 footer | 10 to 20 guests |
| Nizza | 630 9th Avenue | “Over 30 gluten free dishes” | None on the pages read |
| Gramercy Tavern | 42 East 20th Street | Event kit promises to accommodate allergies; no year | Private room for up to 20 |
| Via Carota | 51 Grove Street | Several vegan, vegetarian and gluten free options | No reservations; party of eight or fewer advised |
How these eight were chosen: each restaurant’s own site had to print a dietary statement or label, and six of the eight also print a group rule or table limit. The guide compares what is published, ranks no one, judges no kitchen and names both pages where they disagree.
Can a group book a celiac-safe restaurant?
On the pages read, Senza Gluten is the only one of the eight that describes its whole operation as gluten-free. Its home page says “our kitchen and dining rooms are strictly gluten-free,” and its menu page states its own limit: “We have a very small kitchen. We do our very best to avoid cross-contact if you have food allergies, but due to the nature of our menu and the size of our kitchen there is always a small risk of contamination.” It urges guests with multiple allergies to “call ahead and discuss your dietary needs with the chef directly.” That paragraph is signed “Updated March 2015,” so confirm it still describes the kitchen. Whether the wording suits a guest with celiac disease is a question for the guest and the restaurant, not this guide.
No party-size rule or deposit is printed on the pages read, and the contact page lists +1 212-475-7775 for reservations. Payment needs its own question: the contact page says “WE ACCEPT CASH ONLY,” while the menu page says “WE ACCEPT AMERICAN EXPRESS CARDS OR CASH ONLY.” Ask which applies before the table plans how to split the bill.
Can a vegetarian eat the tasting menu at an Italian restaurant?
At Rezdôra, a vegetarian tasting is available, but the full table has to take part. As of October 2026 the menus page lists “*Vegetarian Tasting Available,” “The Full Table Must Participate in The Tasting” and “Please Allow for A 2 Hour Experience.” The price depends on the page, $110 on the menus page and $98 per guest on the FAQ page, and neither shows a date; the prix fixe guide lists that split beside other set menus.
The gluten-free FAQ sets the limit: “we are not able to offer a gluten-free version of our regional pasta tasting menu or any stuffed pastas,” though it offers two types of gluten-free pasta otherwise. Taken together, a table that includes a gluten-free guest cannot all take the regional pasta tasting as printed, and the pages do not say whether the vegetarian tasting can be made gluten-free. Rezdôra’s largest-party FAQ sends “parties of 6 or more” to a private dining form, which is where a dietary list belongs.
Is there a vegan menu at an old-school Italian restaurant in NYC?
On the pages read, John’s of 12th Street is the only one of the eight with a separate vegan menu. Its About page says it has served “traditional gravy and red-sauce Italian food” since 1908 and offered “a full VEGAN menu for more than 10 years.” The Menus page adds: “We use dedicated cooking utensils for preparing vegan dishes. Please specify VEGAN when ordering.” It marks “CONTAINS NUTS” beside the vegan meatballs, the vegan ragu, and the vegan cannoli, ice cream and tiramisu, so a vegan birthday dessert and a nut allergy are separate questions. Pasta on both tabs can be gluten-free or whole wheat for $2 more.
For groups, the page marks “Minimum 20 people” and says to call 212-475-9531 after 3PM. The back room “can host 70 guests,” and guests “may order directly from our menu or you may choose one of our 3 group menu options.” Those three menus are not printed on the page, so ask whether any has a vegan version.
What can a gluten-free person eat at an Italian restaurant?
Each restaurant publishes gluten-free differently, as of October 2026:
- Rubirosa gives gluten-free its own menu tab: salads, antipasti, “DePuma’s GF Pasta,” pizzas and a Flourless Chocolate Cake under Gluten Free Desserts.
- Rezdôra offers two gluten-free pastas, none for stuffed pastas or the tasting.
- Lavagna footnotes its dinner menu “Gluten free pasta available plus $2.” The page carries a 2015 footer, so confirm.
- Nizza says it has “over 30 gluten free dishes on our menu,” but the dishes behind its “G.F Friendly Lunch” and “G.F Friendly Dinner” tabs could not be read, so the list is unconfirmed.
Which format fits a table with a dietary restriction?
On the pages read, two of the eight tie the group menu itself to dietary needs in writing: Lavagna and Gramercy Tavern’s event kit. The printed rules point to a format by headcount:
- Up to 8: Via Carota’s Questions page says “We do not offer reservations at this time” and advises “a party of eight or fewer.” It lists “several vegan, vegetarian and gluten free options” and will “always do our best to accommodate allergies and dietary restrictions,” but cannot accommodate outside food, so ask before planning a gluten-free cake from elsewhere (the cake policy guide covers what to ask). A mixed table this size can order à la carte rather than commit to a set menu.
- 8 to 22: Rubirosa’s family-style menu is “fully customizable,” and the page does not say whether it draws on the Gluten-Free tab. The family-style guide covers platter sizes.
- 10 to 20, fixed prix fixe: Lavagna says its menus “are chosen to tailor to your needs and any dietary restrictions,” typically with “two pastas including a vegetarian option.” Its price and the Friday and Saturday limit for 17 to 20 are in the family-style guide; the pages carry a 2015 footer, so confirm each term.
- Up to 20, private room: Gramercy Tavern’s private dining page says the room “can seat up to 20 guests.” Its event kit states “Our culinary team will always accommodate all allergies and dietary restrictions” and keys sample dishes as vegetarian (V), vegan (V+), gluten free (GF) and dairy free (DF). The menus are dated only “as of July 13th” and “as of April 15th,” so confirm.
- 20 to 70: John’s back room, above.
The rule that follows: keep a mixed table à la carte unless every guest opts in, because Rezdôra’s tasting is all or nothing, and take a fixed menu only where the restaurant says in writing that it adapts.
What to ask before you book
- Give numbers. “Two gluten-free, one vegan, one tree-nut allergy” can be checked against a menu. John’s inquiry form includes an “Additional Information” field marked optional, so raise the list in the first message; The Private Room explains why to raise allergies before a contract.
- Ask the price of the swap. On the pages read, only John’s and Lavagna publish one: $2.
- Ask how the kitchen keeps dishes apart. On the pages read, only Senza Gluten and John’s (for vegan dishes) describe a practice.
- Ask about dessert and payment. John’s vegan desserts carry the nut warning, and Senza Gluten’s pages disagree on cards.
These are each restaurant’s own statements, not guarantees for a dish or a guest.
Frequently asked questions
Can a group book a celiac-safe restaurant?
Senza Gluten at 206 Sullivan Street says its kitchen and dining rooms are strictly gluten-free, and its menu page adds that “there is always a small risk of contamination.” That paragraph is dated March 2015 and no group rule is printed on the pages read. Celiac guests should confirm with the restaurant.
Can a vegetarian eat the tasting menu at an Italian restaurant?
At Rezdôra, 27 East 20th Street, a vegetarian tasting is available, but the menus page says the full table must take part and to allow 2 hours. The menus page prints $110 for the regional pasta tasting, while the FAQ page prints $98 per guest.
Is there a vegan menu at an old-school Italian restaurant in NYC?
John’s of 12th Street, at 302 East 12th Street, says it has offered a full vegan menu for more than 10 years and uses dedicated cooking utensils for vegan dishes. Several are marked CONTAINS NUTS, and group bookings need a minimum of 20 people, by phone after 3PM.
What can a gluten-free person eat at an Italian restaurant?
Gluten-free pasta is a swap or a separate tab: Rezdôra has two kinds but none for stuffed pasta or its tasting, John’s and Lavagna charge $2 more, and Rubirosa prints a Gluten-Free menu tab. Confirm with the restaurant.


